The Reasons Why Amazon Mechanical Turk No Longer Accepts International Turkers
As
many of you may have heard, Amazon is not approving international Mturk
accounts anymore. In 2012 Amazon put a hold on accepting new worker accounts
for a couple of months. When they started accepting new workers again, it was
only for workers in the United States.
There
are three reasons for this:
Fraud - Amazon was having a
difficult time verifying these accounts and a lot of fraud was occurring from
outside the United States. Multiple accounts, sweatshops, money transfers and
other Amazon TOS violations were occurring on these international accounts.
Amazon would close the worker account and then they would simply open a new
one. If you want to see some of this fraud, take a look at this forum- Romanian Mturk Forum. Over 300 pages long
and 6000 posts. Almost every page of this forum has discussions on how to break
Amazon's TOS. It is no longer active forum because of the halts on new
international accounts.
Complaints - Requester complaints
about the quality of work is the second reason. I personally know quite a few
workers outside of the US that are excellent turkers and speak and write
English better than many Americans. Because of the constant stream of
complaints to Amazon about the poor quality of work from international IP
addresses, something had to be done.
Since fraudulent workers outside of the US were not required to verify
their accounts, they could just make a new account and get back to work under a
different user ID.
Blocks - Blocks are a way Amazon
to monitor worker accounts, although Amazon does not tell requesters this. When
a worker account starts accumulating blocks from requesters, the workers
account is suspended and reviewed by someone at Mturk. A requester could block
a US worker and over time if that worker is not preforming well, they are
removed completely from the worker pool and cannot make a new account. With the
international accounts, a worker would simply change IP address and make a new
account and set up a click script to automatically cheat HITs until blocked
.
Since
Americans are verified using Social Security numbers, bank accounts, credit
cards and addresses, American workers would protect and guard their accounts to
ensure they are not suspended. This is NOT to say that international workers do
not have a professional work ethic or are all out to cheat the system, it is
just an additional restriction on American workers have to ensure that they can
never make multiple accounts.
Requesters
are starting to take notice of this. The worker pool of cheap labor is getting
smaller every day. Some requesters feel it is ethical to pay a worker $1-$2 for
an hours worth of work. American workers, for the most part, will not work for
this pay. New workers, international workers and naive turkers were the ones
completing these tasks. Now, this substandard work is not being completed in a
timely fashion anymore.
For
instance, CastingWords is now making their own
interface because they need these international workers.
So
please, people in India, Pakistan and other foreign countries, please stop
sending me emails asking me how to get your accounts verified. It is not going
to happen. And to all the workers out there, protect your accounts no matter
what country you are from.
No comments:
Post a Comment